I recently returned to Austria for a retreat organized by the Institute of Media Archeology, led by Elisabeth Schimana. We stayed at Neuhauser Kunstmühle in Hohenberg, an old villa and printing mill surrounded by beautiful countryside. There were familiar faces from last year and new people to get to know. We cooked, shared meals, and took walks. The presentations were short and thought provoking and the conversations were long and fascinating.




After last year’s gathering in St. Pölten, I wrote about intellectual intimacy: what becomes possible when we spend time together, share unfinished ideas, and allow someone else’s thinking to affect our own. In Hohenberg, as we discussed demystifying AI, I found myself returning to this idea. Could intellectual intimacy be a way of getting to know AI, too?
I think that the idea to demystify AI often involves the black box metaphor. Open it, explain the mechanism, and we will understand what we are dealing with. Yet an explanation of how a response is generated cannot, on its own, fully explain the condition we are facing which is called AI. And while understanding the mechanism is important, it leaves questions about the experience still open.
Our discussions about how to approach demystification spanned the histories and narratives surrounding AI, the human labor and material resources behind it, and the political and economic interests shaping its development. We questioned what counts as intelligence, whose knowledge becomes visible, and how these technologies influence our behavior and trust. We also considered how exhibitions, play, and participation could invite people to explore these questions through their own experiences.









But the discussions that stayed with me the most were the ones about magic, divination, and “puzzlement,” a notion Maxime Le Calve brought into the conversation. Could remaining puzzled by AI be part of demystifying it? When something confuses or surprises us, perhaps we can stay with it a little longer. The feeling that we already understand it can close off that curiosity.
We hear promises of liberation from work, fears of extinction, predictions of climate catastrophe, and visions of a future we are told we must prepare for. Such stories give us roles to inhabit before we have even used a system. We may approach it already expecting to be impressed, threatened, or disappointed. These expectations deserve examination, too. What might they prevent us from noticing or asking?


This brings me back to intellectual intimacy and the time it takes to get to know someone or something. We can enter a conversation with ideas of our own and yet allow the exchange to complicate them. Each encounter can help us understand more while opening questions we could not have asked before. Perhaps we can try to demystify AI and still allow it to keep surprising us. Come to think of it, the people I love the most are the ones I still can’t quite figure out.




